Historic view of the church

History

Crossroads of Greenwich

First Presbyterian has worshiped on the corner of Putnam Avenue and Lafayette Place at the top of Greenwich Avenue, literally the Crossroads of Greenwich, since 1881.

Greenwich Avenue in the 1880s

After the Civil War, Greenwich was a small community of less than 8000. Greenwich Avenue was not yet paved, and the first telephone had just been installed across the street in the Lenox House Hotel. Still a small farming community, fifteen trains stopped in Greenwich, eastbound and westbound, with an extra train each day on Sunday for day trips to the shore.

Progress was the watchword, and growth was in the air. Greenwich was becoming an enclave of wealthy New Yorkers.

In the 1880s, Second Congregational Church, located just down the street, was full when a group of its parishioners ("men of sincere piety, mature judgment and earnest zeal in Christ's kingdom") proposed the creation of a new Presbyterian Church. First Presbyterian grew from this humble beginning with 33 members and soon after, 66 teachers and students in its Sunday School. Its first service was held on Easter Sunday, 1881.

Past Senior Ministers

Rollin A. Sawyer1881-1884
J. Howard Hobbs1885-1889
John T. Wills1889-1897
Robert L. Jackson1897-1900
Sanford H. Cobb1900-1901
William B. Waller1901-1911
Frank M. Carson1912-1918
Frank A. Hosmer1920-1928
James E. Oastler1929-1933
Minot C. Morgan1933-1950
Thomas W. Graham1950-1951
C. John L. Bates1951-1965
George A. Pera1965-1978
Robert E. Sanders1978-1980
Raymond F. Kent1980-1981
Richard H. Stearns1981-1994
Thomas A. Hughart1995-1997
William A. Evertsberg1997-2013
Steve Plunkett2014-2016
Sean Miller2016-2019
Mark Montgomery2019-2021
Lynn and Mark Barger-Elliott2021-2022
Lindley DeGarmo2024-2026

Location and Parking

Although the First Presbyterian address is 1 West Putnam Avenue, the entrance to the main church building and sanctuary is located directly under the white steeple from the Lafayette Place side of the building.

Handicapped drop off and parking is directly adjacent to the church in the turnaround driveway. Parking space directly adjacent to the main building is limited and often restricted for non-handicapped use.

General parking is available in the municipal lot on Lafayette Place, north of the church building, or in metered spaces on Lafayette Place. On Sundays and evenings only, parking is also available across the street in unused retail parking space.

Church entrance under the white steeple